x
N
G
The Cheese Sauce That Outlived the Restaurant
A copycat recipe for New Yorkers Mumbai’s legendary nachos — and a small act of remembrance.
There’s a particular kind of grief that comes with a restaurant shutting down. Not the dramatic kind — no one holds a funeral — but the quiet, dawning kind. The realisation that the next time you’re craving that thing, there’s nowhere left to go.
New Yorkers, its flagship at Marine Drive and then a few smaller branches much later was the city’s most beloved continental institution, opened in 1981. Coincidentally, the same year I was born. I didn’t discover it as an infant, obviously — but when I did, there were innumerable family get togethers there. Now this is something my nephew never got to be part of, but surprise! he can now (he loves this sauce)
A Different Era of Eating Out
To understand New Yorkers, you have to understand what “continental food” meant in Bombay in the eighties and nineties. It was gloriously made-up. A mishmash of global cuisine with no particular allegiance to authenticity — and that was entirely the point. Recipes were converted to suit the Indian palate: a little more spice, definitely more punch, and let’s say Richer, bolder, and its DNA defintely desi in its interpretation of the foreign.
Mexican food was virtually unheard of in Bombay then. Taco Bell was something your NRI uncle mentioned in passing, something you filed away as belonging to another world. And yet, New Yorkers smuggled American food into the city — nachos, enchiladas (that ketychupy sauce), onion rings that were genuinely some of the best you’ve ever had (recipe coming soon, I promise).
The restaurant, surrounded by vegetarian families, and with an almost accidental genius, its flagship dish — those nachos, that cheese sauce — was completely vegetarian. The target audience was pitch perfect: people who had travelled abroad, come back with stories of what they ate, and wanted something that resonated.
The Sauce
Let’s talk about the cheese sauce, because that is what this is really about.
It was yellow. Aggressively, weirdly yellow. Gooey in a way that’s sublimely strange but — it held its shape on the chip just long enough for you to lift it to your mouth before it gave way entirely. It was addictive : no one ate it once. Every single person at the table, without exception, could not resist going back for more.
I’ve tried to replicate it. I’ve come genuinely close. The flavour is there. The spice is there. What I haven’t been able to crack is that specific shade of yellow, that particular quality of gooeyness that I suspect involved either a processed cheese blend I haven’t identified yet, or some institutional kitchen magic that simply doesn’t translate to a home stove. If you crack it, please tell me.
New Yorkers shut down a couple of years ago. Some of its iconic recipes deserve to continue — not as museum pieces, but as living things, made in home kitchens, eaten while still bubbling hot.
Which brings me to the most important instruction in this entire post: eat this sauce immediately. The moment it cools, it forms a skin, hardens, and youve to work on it again. If that happens, don’t panic — a splash of milk and gentle heat brings it right back. But ideally, have your chips ready, your people around the table.
An Iconic recipe
New Yorkers-Style Nachos with Cheese Sauce
Serves 3–4 | Prep: 15 mins | Cook: 20 mins
For the Homemade Nacho Chips
While ill give this separately, a pro tip is to bake your chips which are sliced from the dough and then fry them for a crunchier crunch.
For the Cheese Sauce
Ingredients
- 1 tbsp butter
- 1 tbsp maida (all-purpose flour)
- 1 cup warm milk
- ¾ cup grated Amul processed cheese
- 1 slice Amul cheese (yes, really)
- ¼ tsp white pepper
- ¼ tsp red chilli powder / paprika
- Salt to taste
- 1–2 tsp jalapeño brine or mild vinegar
- 1 tsp mustard sauce (American style mustard)
- Optional: Half a pack of stock powder or a pinch of ajinomoto
Method
- Melt butter, add flour — cook 1 minute (no browning).
- Whisk in warm milk slowly until thick and smooth.
- Lower heat, add cheese gradually, stirring constantly.
- Add spices, salt, jalapeño brine, rest of the ingredients
- Cook till glossy and spoon-coating thick.
Notes
- Eat immediately while the sauce is bubbling hot
- If the sauce firms up, add a splash of milk and reheat gently — it comes back beautifully
- The yellowness remains elusive. If you solve it, we talk.
New Yorkers is shut. But this recipe is very much alive. Make it, eat it fast, and remember the restaurant that made Bombay fall in love with a cheese sauce.
Nikhil Merchant
Hospitality Writer | Culinary & Bar Consultant | Restaurateur | Brand Evangelist